Example review
History statement
UCL History BA · University of Edinburgh History MA (Hons) · University of Warwick BA History · University of Bristol BA History · Durham University History
An example review of one of our own sample statements, in exactly the format you'll get. We never show a statement a student has submitted: those stay private.
This is already a great statement and could be submitted as it is. It has a clear intellectual theme, original archival findings and close engagement with named historians. The changes below are optional refinements, and removing the single-university module names is the one most worth making.
Best thing about it
Real, original historical work: you test popular memory against your own evidence, as in 'of the 412 appeals I catalogued, only 19 were made on grounds of conscience', and set it against published arguments.
Biggest thing to fix
Naming UCL's and Warwick's modules in a statement all five universities will read, and squeezing the conclusion into the last sentence of P3.
Optional polish
None of these are needed to submit, but each would make your statement even stronger. Most valuable first.
- 1
Remove the single-university module names
Course alignmentReplace 'such as Approaching History at UCL' and 'in Warwick's Making of the Modern World' with general descriptions of the same kind of study (historical method and historiography; global and transnational history). Keep each one about the same length.
- 2
Give the conclusion its own paragraph
ConclusionMove the sentence beginning 'Across these projects' into a new final paragraph. This changes no characters. If you free any space elsewhere, add one short clause on where you want to take this work next, using [your own direction].
- 3
Swap the English Literature sentence for a finding
Depth of learning and technical contentReplace it, at about the same length (around 140 characters), with one concrete thing close reading of the Preston minutes revealed, such as a recurring phrase and what it showed about how the committee saw the poor.
- 4
Add a one-clause spark to P3
Paragraph structureReplace 'Outside school,' with a short clause linking back to your interest in institutional records, such as 'Wanting to handle such records myself,' (about 20 extra characters). Pay for it by shortening 'To place this in a wider frame, I read' to 'I then read'.
- 5
Cut the university links down to two
Implications and link to the courseOnce the module names are gone, end P2 on your own insight about tracing a commodity across continents and drop the 'I hope to develop' clause. Use those characters for the conclusion or the close-reading finding.
Want 1:1 help with your statement?
Book a call with Chat University to talk through this review and plan your next draft.
How you scored
Lowest first. Open one to see the quotes behind it and how to fix it.
Conclusion3.5/5
The closing sentence goes full circle back to the introduction in fresh words, but it's one sentence inside P3, not a conclusion paragraph.
Working
It echoes the opening idea of people surviving in other people's records without repeating its wording.
“the historian's task is to recover the people inside them without forgetting why those records were made”
Not working
It's too brief to bring together the interest, the exploration and where you want to go next.
“Across these projects I have learned that the most revealing evidence often comes from routine administrative records”
Fix: Make this its own paragraph. Use the space freed by trimming elsewhere (about 100 characters) to add a clause on where you want to take this next, such as [the kind of records or period you want to research].
What should be excluded4/5
No questions, quotations, prestige name-dropping or irrelevant work experience. One sentence about ordinary school subjects adds little.
Working
The volunteering is directly relevant to History and is judged on what you learned from it.
“This taught me that conscription was experienced mainly as an economic negotiation between families and the state”
Not working
This is generic school-subject content with no specific finding behind it.
“English Literature has also trained me to read language closely, which I now apply to the language of official minutes as much as to novels.”
Fix: Swap this sentence for a specific finding from your own close reading of the relief committee minutes.
Course alignment8.5/10
Every topic suits all five History degrees, but two sentences name a specific university's module, which reads oddly at the other four. (Judged with less certainty: we had limited information about some of your courses.)
Working
The theme of method and source criticism fits the compulsory historiography and method courses at UCL, Edinburgh, Warwick, Bristol (Approaching the Past) and Durham (historiography in Year 2).
“That tension, between the voice in a source and the institution that recorded it, is what I want to study at university”
Not working
Edinburgh, Warwick, Bristol and Durham will all read this. Naming a UCL module tells four of your five choices they aren't the focus.
“particularly in modules on historical method such as Approaching History at UCL.”
Fix: Replace both module names with general descriptions of the same kind of study (historical method and historiography; global and transnational history). Every one of your five courses offers these. Keep each replacement about the same length.
Introduction8.5/10
A specific, intellectual spark that sets up the whole statement. It runs about 260 characters over the target and ends on a single-university reference.
Working
The opening line is personal and precise, and it states the theme that the rest of the statement follows.
“History interests me most where ordinary people survive only in records written by someone else.”
Not working
It ends on a module at one university instead of on your own idea.
“particularly in modules on historical method such as Approaching History at UCL.”
Fix: Keep the Ginzburg and Davis material. Replace the UCL reference with a general phrase about historical method so the introduction ends on your theme.
Implications and link to the course8.5/10
Implications are strong and specific to the discipline. The 'study this at university' link appears in all three paragraphs, which is one too many.
Working
It draws a lesson for historical method from your own data.
“the cases historians find most dramatic are not always the most typical”
Not working
There are three university links in three paragraphs, and two of them name single universities.
“an approach I hope to develop in Warwick's Making of the Modern World.”
Fix: Keep the dissertation link in P3 and the theme statement in P1. In P2, end on the idea of tracing a commodity across continents, or link it to global history in general terms.
Paragraph structure13/15
Both body paragraphs are well built. P3's spark is thin, and there's no standalone conclusion, so the structure is introduction plus two body paragraphs with a tacked-on ending.
Working
P2 opens by linking straight back to the introduction's theme, which gives the statement a clear thread.
“My A-level coursework on the Lancashire Cotton Famine of 1861 to 1865 tested this directly.”
Not working
The closing reflection is buried in the body paragraph instead of standing alone as a conclusion.
“Across these projects I have learned that the most revealing evidence often comes from routine administrative records”
Fix: Move the final sentence of P3 into its own short paragraph. This changes no characters. Then give P3 a one-clause spark.
Supercurricular selection14/15
Four well-chosen, connected topic areas, all clearly beyond the syllabus, with real archival work of the kind a History degree involves.
Working
Hands-on archival work that is exactly what a History dissertation involves.
“cataloguing the papers of a First World War Military Service Tribunal for public use”
Not working
You don't say why you chose the record office, so the activity looks a little like it was whatever was available, even though it clearly wasn't.
“Outside school, I volunteered for six months at my county record office”
Fix: Add a short clause saying what drew you to the tribunal papers. Make it a swap for 'Outside school,' and trim elsewhere in the paragraph.
Depth of learning and technical content23.5/25
Unusually specific: original findings, concrete numbers and arguments tested against named historians. Only one sentence is generic.
Working
Original quantitative evidence that overturns a popular assumption.
“of the 412 appeals I catalogued, only 19 were made on grounds of conscience”
Not working
This is the one generic claim. It says you read closely but shows nothing you found by doing so.
“English Literature has also trained me to read language closely, which I now apply to the language of official minutes as much as to novels.”
Fix: Replace the English Literature sentence with one concrete thing that close reading of the Preston minutes showed you, at about the same length.
Writing quality and length5/5
3,974 characters, within the target band. The prose is mature, precise and free of clichés, and it sounds like a real student thinking.
Working
Precise, economical phrasing.
“every word reaches us through questions chosen by inquisitors hunting for heresy”
Fix: Keep every change length-neutral so the statement stays between 3,950 and 4,000 characters.
Paragraph check
Every body paragraph needs a spark, what you did, what you learned and why it matters. Here's each one at a glance; open a paragraph below for the detail.
| Paragraph | Spark | Action | Learning | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 · Lancashire Cotton Famine coursework and Beckert's global cotton history | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| 3 · Record office volunteering on WWI Military Service Tribunals, Gregory, with a closing sentence acting as conclusion | ◐ Partly | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
Paragraph 2 · Lancashire Cotton Famine coursework and Beckert's global cotton history
Has everything it needs
Paragraph 2 · Lancashire Cotton Famine coursework and Beckert's global cotton history
Has everything it needs
Your paragraph
My A-level coursework on the Lancashire Cotton Famine of 1861 to 1865 tested this directly. The famine is often cited as proof of working-class solidarity with the Union, because Manchester workers publicly supported Lincoln despite losing their jobs to the blockade. Using digitised local newspapers and the minutes of the Preston relief committee, I found that meetings opposing the blockade were reported as widely as those supporting it, and that relief committees repeatedly made aid conditional on attending sewing classes and schools. I concluded that the famous support was real but not representative, and that the memory of it was shaped by the reformers who printed and repeated it. A-level Economics helped me explain why the shock was so severe: with few alternative suppliers, raw cotton prices rose almost fourfold. Reading Sven Beckert's Empire of Cotton then widened my view, because he shows how the same shortage pushed Britain to expand cotton growing in India and Egypt, binding peasant farmers into a global commodity market. I learned that a local crisis can only be explained by tracing the commodity across continents, an approach I hope to develop in Warwick's Making of the Modern World. English Literature has also trained me to read language closely, which I now apply to the language of official minutes as much as to novels.
Working
Excellent primary-source work with a clear argument. Only the closing English Literature sentence is weak, and the university link names a single university.
What's good
- Says what made you want to explore this
- Says what you actually did
- Says specifically what you learned
- Explains why it matters beyond your own work
- Links it to what you want to study at university
Paragraph 3 · Record office volunteering on WWI Military Service Tribunals, Gregory, with a closing sentence acting as conclusion
Partly there: spark
Paragraph 3 · Record office volunteering on WWI Military Service Tribunals, Gregory, with a closing sentence acting as conclusion
Partly there: spark
Your paragraph
Outside school, I volunteered for six months at my county record office, cataloguing the papers of a First World War Military Service Tribunal for public use. Popular memory of the tribunals centres on conscientious objectors, but of the 412 appeals I catalogued, only 19 were made on grounds of conscience. Most came from small employers and widowed mothers arguing that a son or worker was essential to a farm or shop. This taught me that conscription was experienced mainly as an economic negotiation between families and the state, and that the cases historians find most dramatic are not always the most typical. It also made me careful about what survives: many tribunal records were deliberately destroyed after 1921, so a surviving collection may itself be unrepresentative. To place this in a wider frame, I read Adrian Gregory's The Last Great War, which argues that British support for the war rested on a shared language of sacrifice. My catalogue suggests that this language was bargained over locally, with families accepting sacrifice in principle while contesting who should bear it. I have since begun comparing tribunal decisions in rural and urban districts to test whether farming areas won more exemptions, and I would like to pursue questions of this kind through archival research in a dissertation. Across these projects I have learned that the most revealing evidence often comes from routine administrative records, and that the historian's task is to recover the people inside them without forgetting why those records were made.
Working Partly there
The strongest paragraph: original data tested against a published argument. It never says why you went to the record office, and the conclusion is squeezed into its last sentence.
What's good
- Says what you actually did
- Says specifically what you learned
- Explains why it matters beyond your own work
- Links it to what you want to study at university
What to improve
- The reason you explored this is only hinted at. Make it explicit. (highlighted in amber)
How to link a paragraph to university (you have 2; one or two is enough)
End one or two of your strongest paragraphs with a sentence tying what you learned to what you want to study next. Link it to something all five of your courses teach, not one university's module, because every university reads the same statement.
A template
For example, at the end of your paragraph on Lancashire Cotton Famine coursework and Beckert's global cotton history:
“This is something I want to explore further at university, particularly [an area all five of your courses teach].”
From a strong History statement
“I would like to pursue questions of this kind through archival research in a dissertation.”
Put it at the end of the paragraph, after why it matters. Once or twice is enough: not in every paragraph.
What a fix looks like
Examples only. Write your version in your own words, filling the [brackets] with what you actually did.
Yours
“particularly in modules on historical method such as Approaching History at UCL.”
Stronger
“particularly in modules on historical method, historiography and source criticism.”
Takes out the UCL-only reference so the sentence works for all five universities, at almost the same length.
2 more examples
Yours
“English Literature has also trained me to read language closely, which I now apply to the language of official minutes as much as to novels.”
Stronger
“Reading the minutes closely, I noticed the committee repeatedly described claimants as [recurring phrase], which showed me that [what this revealed about how relief was given].”
Replaces a general claim about a school subject with a specific finding from your own primary-source work, at roughly the same length. Only use it if the minutes actually show this.
Yours
“an approach I hope to develop in Warwick's Making of the Modern World.”
Stronger
“an approach I hope to develop through global and transnational history.”
Removes the Warwick-only module name. Alternatively, cut the clause entirely and end the sentence at 'continents' to free about 70 characters for the conclusion.
More detail
Cut these (1)
School content. Generic claim about a school subject with no specific learning. Replace it with a concrete close-reading finding of the same length.
“English Literature has also trained me to read language closely, which I now apply to the language of official minutes as much as to novels.”
Questions to ask yourself (5)
- What first made you contact the county record office? Was it the Ginzburg reading, the coursework, or something else?
- What have the rural and urban tribunal comparisons shown so far, even provisionally?
- Which exact words or phrases in the Preston relief minutes told you something the newspapers didn't?
- If you could research one collection of administrative records at university, what would it be and why?
- Where do you think your own reconstructions risk filling gaps with imagination, as you say Davis's does?
Facts to double-check (3)
“raw cotton prices rose almost fourfold”
Check the figure against your source and say which period it covers (for example 1861 to 1864). An interviewer may ask where the number comes from.
“many tribunal records were deliberately destroyed after 1921”
Broadly correct (the government ordered the destruction of most tribunal papers), but confirm the date and wording against the record office's own catalogue notes.
“of the 412 appeals I catalogued, only 19 were made on grounds of conscience”
Make sure these counts exactly match your catalogue. They are your strongest evidence and very likely to come up at interview.
Step-by-step plan for your next draft
- Net change needed: zero. You're at 3,974 characters, so every edit must be a like-for-like swap that keeps you between 3,950 and 4,000.
- Replace the UCL and Warwick module names with general descriptions of similar length.
- Move the final sentence of P3 into its own conclusion paragraph (no change in length).
- Swap the English Literature sentence for a specific finding from the Preston minutes (about 140 characters each way).
- Replace 'Outside school,' with a short spark clause and shorten 'To place this in a wider frame, I read' to pay for it.
- Check the fourfold price rise, the 1921 destruction date and your 412/19 figures before submitting, then recheck the final character count.
Review context
- No supercurricular notes were provided, so activities are judged only from the statement text.
- Durham has no module list on file, so its fit is judged from the course description. Course alignment is therefore lower confidence.
- The A-level History coursework on the Cotton Famine is assumed to be the self-chosen NEA topic. That makes it acceptable self-directed work, not ordinary school content.
Get this for your own statement
Checked against your five courses. On screen in minutes, and emailed to you to keep.
Get my review: £10